Butyrate vs. Probiotics: What’s The Difference?

“I tried every probiotic on the shelf. Nothing worked.”

This was Sarah’s story, maybe it’s yours, too. She had bloating after every meal, couldn’t go to the bathroom for days, and felt like her gut ruled her life. Naturally, she reached for probiotics—the go-to supplement for gut health.

But after months of trying brand after brand, nothing changed. That’s when she learned about something called butyrate—a postbiotic, not a probiotic.

Within weeks of starting butyrate, the bloating eased. Bathroom visits became regular. Her mood even lifted.

So what gives? If probiotics are supposed to be the heroes of the gut, why didn’t they help? And what exactly is butyrate?

Let’s break it down.

Probiotic vs. Postbiotic: What’s the Difference?

We hear about probiotics constantly, but postbiotics? Not so much.

Here’s the key distinction:

• Probiotics are living bacteria (or sometimes inactivated ones) that you consume to support a healthier gut microbiome. They’re often species like Lactobacillus or Bifidobacteria.
• Butyrate is a postbiotic—a beneficial metabolite produced when certain gut bacteria break down resistant starch, a type of fiber, in the colon. It’s not alive like a probiotic. It’s a short-chain fatty acid (SCFA) with powerful effects on the gut and beyond.

In other words, probiotics can make postbiotics—but not all do. And most probiotic supplements don’t contain the bacteria that are capable of producing butyrate.

How Do Probiotics And Butyrate Work Together?

Think of your gut like a garden.

• Probiotics are like planting seeds—they introduce beneficial bacteria.
• Butyrate is like compost—it’s the nutrient-rich result that feeds the soil (your gut lining) and supports everything growing there.

While probiotics may help shift the microbiome toward more balance, butyrate directly nourishes and strengthens the gut barrier, supports anti-inflammatory processes, and even travels through the bloodstream to benefit the brain and immune system.

Where probiotics act mostly in the gut, butyrate works systemically.

Why Butyrate Might Work When Probiotics Don’t

Probiotics are helpful—but they’re not a cure-all.

Some common reasons probiotics may not work:

• Your microbiome may not have the right balance of species to allow them to thrive
• You’re not getting butyrate-producing strains (like Clostridium or Eubacterium) in your supplement
• You may already have too much of certain probiotic strains—yes, even “good” bacteria can become imbalanced

This is where butyrate shines. It bypasses the need for the right bacterial conditions and goes straight to work.

In fact, research shows that:

• Butyrate supplementation may help relieve IBS (irritable bowel syndrome)  symptoms like bloating, pain, constipation, and diarrhea.
• It may help strengthen the gut lining and repair damage from inflammation or leaky gut.
• It may support mood and brain clarity via the gut-brain axis.

Plus, it’s well tolerated, with a very low-risk side effect profile. Just make sure you pay close attention to your gut health and notice any changes that start to arise. 

Do You Need Both Butyrate And Probiotics? Maybe.

Butyrate and probiotics aren’t rivals—they’re teammates.

You can absolutely take them together:

• Probiotics may help populate your gut with beneficial species.
• Butyrate ensures your gut lining stays strong and supported.
• Together, they may create a more complete gut support strategy.

Some people start with probiotics. Others start with butyrate. Some need both. The right protocol depends on your unique gut terrain.

Final Takeaway: Listen To Your Gut, Literally

If you’ve tried probiotics and felt… nothing, that doesn’t mean your gut is beyond help. It might just mean you need a different tool.

Butyrate is not a probiotic—it’s a postbiotic with powerful benefits for gut, brain, immune, and inflammatory health.

It works differently, and for many, it works better.

Your gut has its own language. Symptoms are signals. If probiotics didn’t work for you, don’t give up on your gut health. Try butyrate. Or try both. You may be one supplement away from the gut relief you’ve been searching for.

References:

1. Amiri P, Hosseini SA, Ghaffari S, et al. Role of Butyrate, a Gut Microbiota-Derived Metabolite, in Cardiovascular Diseases: A comprehensive narrative review. Front Pharmacol. 2022;12:837509. Published 2022 Feb 2. doi:10.3389/fphar.2021.837509
2. Bridgeman SC, Northrop W, Melton PE, Ellison GC, Newsholme P, Mamotte CDS. Butyrate generated by gut microbiota and its therapeutic role in metabolic syndrome. Pharmacol Res. 2020;160:105174. doi:10.1016/j.phrs.2020.105174
3. Canani RB, Costanzo MD, Leone L, Pedata M, Meli R, Calignano A. Potential beneficial effects of butyrate in intestinal and extraintestinal diseases. World J Gastroenterol. 2011;17(12):1519-1528. doi:10.3748/wjg.v17.i12.1519
4. Cazzaniga M, Cardinali M, Di Pierro F, Zonzini GB, Palazzi CM, Gregoretti A, Zerbinati N, Guasti L, Bertuccioli A. The Potential Role of Probiotics, Especially Butyrate Producers, in the Management of Gastrointestinal Mucositis Induced by Oncologic Chemo-Radiotherapy. International Journal of Molecular Sciences. 2024; 25(4):2306. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijms25042306
5. Gąsiorowska A, Romanowski M, Walecka-Kapica E, et al. Effects of Microencapsulated Sodium Butyrate, Probiotics and Short Chain Fructooligosaccharides in Patients with Irritable Bowel Syndrome: A Study Protocol of a Randomized Double-Blind Placebo-Controlled Trial. J Clin Med. 2022;11(21):6587. Published 2022 Nov 7. doi:10.3390/jcm11216587
6. Geirnaert A, Calatayud M, Grootaert C, et al. Butyrate-producing bacteria supplemented in vitro to Crohn's disease patient microbiota increased butyrate production and enhanced intestinal epithelial barrier integrity. Sci Rep. 2017;7(1):11450. Published 2017 Sep 13. doi:10.1038/s41598-017-11734-8
7. Nozu T, Miyagishi S, Nozu R, Takakusaki K, Okumura T. Butyrate inhibits visceral allodynia and colonic hyperpermeability in rat models of irritable bowel syndrome. Sci Rep. 2019;9(1):19603. Published 2019 Dec 20. doi:10.1038/s41598-019-56132-4
8. Singh V, Lee G, Son H, et al. Butyrate producers, "The Sentinel of Gut": Their intestinal significance with and beyond butyrate, and prospective use as microbial therapeutics. Front Microbiol. 2023;13:1103836. Published 2023 Jan 12. doi:10.3389/fmicb.2022.1103836
9. Załęski A, Banaszkiewicz A, Walkowiak J. Butyric acid in irritable bowel syndrome. Prz Gastroenterol. 2013;8(6):350-353. doi:10.5114/pg.2013.39917
10. Zhu LB, Zhang YC, Huang HH, Lin J. Prospects for clinical applications of butyrate-producing bacteria. World J Clin Pediatr. 2021;10(5):84-92. Published 2021 Sep 9. doi:10.5409/wjcp.v10.i5.84